Overview
The raw stats document behind the Treat-ies. Two views: By Category (ranked tables, definitions inline) and By Manager (one card each).
The league is treated as one continuous dynasty, 2022–2025 — the 2022 Yahoo season ("Crown City Legends 08") folded in alongside the 2023–25 Sleeper seasons. Some GM stats only exist for the Sleeper era because the 2022 Yahoo waiver/transaction detail was not fully captured; every category is tagged 2022–25 (all four seasons), 2023–25 only (Sleeper era), or 2024–26 chat only — the group-chat export only reaches back to mid-2024, so chat-based stats cover that window only.
Curtis played only 2022 (and won that title); his card shows that season. Cole is brand-new for 2026 with no history yet. Rodger and Will Holder are former members, shown greyed for context. The 2022 "Dean Spanos" caretaker stretch is attributed entirely to Rodger.
Color legend (ranked tables):
#1 in league
#2 or #3
Second-worst
Worst
Former member
League-Wide Single-Game Records 2022–25
Most-Traded Players 2022–25
How it's measured: times each player changed hands in a completed trade, all four seasons (2022 trade detail recovered from the Yahoo transaction records).
By Stat Category
1. Record & Scoring 2022–25
How it's measured: Wins/Losses, Points For (PF), Points Against (PA), Points Per Week (PPW). Regular season + playoffs, all four seasons. Sorted by PPW.
2. Lineup Efficiency 2022–25
How it's measured: For each week, the best legal lineup is computed from the manager's whole roster. Eff % = points started ÷ best possible. 2022 used a QB/QB/WR/WR/RB/RB/TE/FLEX/K/DEF template; 2023-25 uses QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/TE/FLEX/SUPERFLEX/DEF. 2022 figures use a secondary box-score capture with minor noise.
3. Variance / Consistency 2022–25
How it's measured: Standard deviation of weekly scores. Lower = more consistent. CV % = stdev ÷ mean × 100.
4. All-Play / Median Wins 2022–25
How it's measured: All-play: each week, scored against every other manager — you "win" anyone you outscored. Removes schedule luck. Median wins: beat the week's median score. Median weekly rank: average 1–10 placement per week (lower better).
5. Playoff PPW Gap 2022–25
How it's measured: Average points per week in playoff games minus regular-season average. Positive = scores up in the playoffs (clutch); negative = scores down (choke).
6. Trade Volume 2022–25
How it's measured: Completed trades and distinct trade partners, all four seasons. 2022 had 23 trades (captured at deal level).
7. Trade Quality (Hindsight) 2022–25
How it's measured: For each trade: fpts the acquired players produced after the trade minus the given-up players, through end of 2025. Excludes picks. All four seasons — 2022 trades are linked across the Yahoo→Sleeper move by player name, so a 2022 deal is scored on its full dynasty payoff. Note: earlier trades have a longer measurement window, so 2022 deals look larger by construction.
8. Pick Flow 2022–25
How it's measured: Draft picks gained/given via trade, weighted R1=4 / R2=3 / R3=2 / later=1. All four seasons. 2022 picks: per the keeper-league rules of that era, traded picks were all 2023 rookie picks, and since that draft ran 2 rounds only R1-R2 are counted. "From Dead Teams" = picks acquired from Rodger or Will Holder.
9. Roster Churn 2022–25
How it's measured: Adds/drops via waivers and free agency, plus FAAB spent. Now all four seasons — the 2022 Yahoo waiver log was recovered from a manual Yahoo export and reconciles to the archive move-counts.
10. FAAB Efficiency 2022–25
How it's measured: Fpts produced by FAAB-waiver pickups divided by FAAB dollars spent. All four seasons. Note: the 2022 component is approximate — ~20% of 2022 waiver pickups can't be matched to a scored 2022 game (suspensions, players never rostered during a scored week, name variants), so 2022 efficiency runs slightly low.
11. Player Retention 2023–25 only
How it's measured: Median days a manager holds an acquired player before moving on; count of current players held 700+ days continuously. Sleeper-era only.
12. Draft Deep-Dive 2023–25 only
How it's measured: All three rookie drafts — 2023 (2 rounds), 2024, 2025 (3 rounds each); the 2022 startup draft is excluded. Each pick is scored on a forward production window (2023 picks get 3 NFL seasons, 2024 get 2, 2025 get 1), divided to a per-season rate. Value Over Expectation (VOE): a pick is compared to a bar — the median per-season output of same-position picks taken in the same slot tier (1-3, 4-6, 7-10, 11-15, 16-20, 21-30), pooled across all three drafts. Using the median (not the average) stops one steal from inflating the bar for its whole tier; splitting by position stops a WR being measured against superflex QBs. The metric is deliberately asymmetric: a hit counts in full, but a miss is scaled down by where the pick was spent — a 1st-round bomb dings at full weight, an early-2nd at 0.45, a late-2nd at 0.25, a 3rd-rounder at just 0.10. Spending a premium pick on a bust should hurt; whiffing on a 3rd-round flier barely should. Hits = 100+ fpts/yr; Studs = 200+/yr. Reach points = per-yr production left for a later same-position pick. Caveats: small samples (Greg 2 picks, Will Purvis 3, Mike & Will Holder 4) are noisy; 2025 picks have only one rookie season of data and will move.
Biggest Steals — picks that most beat their draft slot
Biggest Busts — picks that most missed their draft slot
Biggest Reaches — best same-position player still on the board after
13. Schedule Strength 2022–25
How it's measured: Average of each opponent's season-average points. Higher = harder schedule.
14. Clutch — Win % vs Own Avg 2022–25
How it's measured: Win rate when scoring above the manager's own career average vs at-or-below it.
15. Chat Behavior 2024–26 chat only
How it's measured: Messages and reactions in the "Treating" group chat. React:Msg >1 means more reactions than posts. Msgs/Trade is a talk-to-action ratio. Date note: the chat export only reaches back to mid-2024, so this covers roughly July 2024 onward — not the full league history.
16. FAAB Bid Behavior 2022 only
How it's measured: From the 2022 contested-waiver records (winning bid + every losing bid). Contested W-L: waiver claims where 2+ managers bid. Avg overpay vs #2: on wins, how far the winning bid topped the next-highest bid — high = blows the field away, low = snipes by a dollar. 2022 only; Sleeper waiver data does not expose losing bids.
17. Luck 2022–25
How it's measured: Per regular-season game, was your score above or below the week's median? Unlucky loss: you scored above the median and still lost (you played a top-half week, drew a buzzsaw). Lucky win: you scored at/below the median and still won (you drew a cupcake). Luck index: actual regular-season wins minus median-wins — positive = you won more than your scores earned (lucky), negative = unlucky. Opp over/underperf: average gap between your opponents' scores and their own season average — positive = you kept facing hot teams. This measures luck, not skill; high or low is neither good nor bad.
18. Biggest Hater 2024–26 chat only
How it's measured: "Disliked" reactions in the Treating group chat. Date note: the chat export only reaches back to mid-2024, so this is a 2024–26 window, not all four seasons — a manager whose loud era was 2022–23 will look quiet here. Dislikes Given = Disliked reactions a manager sent. Dislike Rate = the share of all their reactions that are Dislikes — this controls for the fact that some people react to everything, so it is a truer per-reaction hostility read. Dislikes Received = dislikes that landed on their own messages, traced by matching each Disliked reaction back to the message it hit (94% matched). Received / 1k Msgs = dislikes received per 1,000 messages posted. Like luck, high or low is neither good nor bad — it just maps where the chat throws shade. The pair table below shows who dislikes whom the most.
Who Dislikes Whom — top dislike pairs across all four seasons of chat
19. Value Finder 2022–25
How it's measured: A cross-channel ROI score. Three ways a manager adds talent — the draft, waivers/FAAB, and trades — each measured as return per unit of cost (draft = VOE per pick, waivers = fpts per FAAB dollar, trades = net fpts per trade). Two adjustments make it fair: (1) small samples are regressed toward the league average — a manager with only 2 draft picks does not get a full draft grade, their number is pulled toward the mean; (2) each channel is converted to a z-score (standard deviations above/below the league mean) so a genuine edge counts big and a near-tie stays a near-tie. The Value Score is the average of the three channel z-scores; positive = an above-average value hunter. Curtis is excluded (2022-only, no Sleeper draft). Trade value still carries the longer-measurement-window bias from earlier seasons.